In the 1920s, a select group of members from the Dorchester Club (an organization dedicated to the study of the occult and esoteric) travel to the rural town of Corbis Wood, just outside of Salem, Massachusetts in the company of famed spiritualist Paul Lemond to ascertain whether or not the house is haunted.
In this episode they continue their investigations, probing into suspicions that Paul Lemond and his manager Herbert are somehow setting them up. Later, the investigators make their first contact with the spirit world!