Even the Podcast is Afraid

In 1974, Ronald Defeo Jr. would commit one of the most brutal acts of murder ever known, in Amityville, NY. In part one of this series, we go in depth on the true story of the Amityville Murders at 112 Ocean Avenue, as Ronnie, also known by his...

Luka would eventually move on from killing small kittens, to murdering his first human, Chinese international student Jun Lin. The murder would set-off one of the biggest international manhunts in Canadian history leading all they way to Europe. In...

Luka Rocco Magnotta, who was the main subject of the Netflix documentary "Dont Fuck with Cats", is a convicted kitten killer & murderer from Canada. In part one of this series, we discuss Luka's abusive childhood, his time as a model, male escort, and...

Hosts of "Even the Podcast is Afraid" read some of the creepiest stories & Creepy Pastas from the darkest parts of the internet, once each month, while bringing their own comedic, narrative edits, & opinions as they critique & rate the stories they...

Joe Exotic's life is reaching a breaking point, as the tension between Joe & Carole Baskin reaches a peak of insanity, prompting Joe to look into hiring someone to murder Carole. In the final episode of this series, the murder for hire gets underway...

Jared Ordis had a chance to chat with Tim Pilleri & Lance Reenstierna, from the highly acclaimed podcast's Crawlspace & Missing Maura Murray. Jared was recently on an episode of Crawlspace, EP.137 Hauntings & Creepy Pastas, where Jared discussed the...

The cat fight between Joe Exotic & Carole Baskin begins. In part three of this series, We look more into the life of Joe at the G.W. Zoo, and take an in depth look at the crazy & dark antics that happened in the Netflix documentary, Tiger King:...

"Hello all you cool cats & kittens!" In part two of this series, we go all in on Joe Exotic's biggest nemesis, Carole Baskin. We learn about Carole's early years as a child, all of Carole's marriages, her time running Wildlife on Easy Street, which...

Joseph Allen Maldonado-Passage, better known as Joe Exotic, is the former G.W. Zoo owner & convicted felon. Joe is the main subject depicted in the popular Netflix documentary, Tiger King: Murder, Mayhem, & Madness. In part one of this series, we dive...

 Hosts of "Even the Podcast is Afraid" read some of the creepiest stories & Creepy Pastas from the darkest parts of the internet, once each month, while bringing their own comedic, narrative edits, & opinions as they critique & rate the stories they...